Out of all the skills a person should focus on developing is communication.
One area of society I feel this is most evident and particularly relevant to the current topic of the 'NEET crisis' is in the supermarket. Many will comment on the harms of young people* spending too much time on Snapchat et al., not really conversing or socialising, i.e. developing social communication skills.
However, supermarket chains seem to be getting off the hook a bit here. We're quick to complain about the increasing prices on food but we should be just as concerned by the disappearing staff.
Once a staple of the entry-level job, or a place where someone could re-enter the workforce, the advent of self-scanning tills has obliterated both opportunities. Doing a weekly or daily shop has become a truly soulless experience.**
![]() |
| A phone tap is no substitute for a friendly smile and 'hello' |
And it comes down to one thing in my opinion. The lack of communication. Or more simply put, the erosion of conversation between customers and staff. Where before you might have a natter with the person scanning your shopping at the checkout, you instead scan your own items while a solitary (usually frazzled) staffer zips between tills getting the red light back to green. No words are spoken beyond a perfunctory 'thanks'.
Case in point
My local Morrison's store in East Kilbride has recently increased the number of self-scan stations. Last night, and on two previous visits now, I've noted not a single person working the checkouts. Customers get their shopping, scan in silence, pay and leave. So much for your friendly marketplace (as they still like to portray themselves in advertising). But again, more importantly where is the chat? I know it sounds flippant but it is (I might have said already) crucial.
Because if it's not hard enough for young people to get the experience of an entry-level job in the first place, it's going to be just as hard convincing their next hiring manager that they have the necessary softer skills to succeed in a higher pressure working environment. For those not going through university where at least they can converse with peers and lecturers, it is doubly hard.
Maybe we're to blame?
It's not really the point of this piece but I also wonder if we're not to blame a little. When we as a society started doing our shopping at the supermarkets instead of the butcher, the bakers and the green grocer, we lost a brilliant part of our communities. Then later we started accepting cheaper goods from the likes of Lidl and Aldi where speed and convenience was placed above a fuller in-store experience. Now there is also Tesco Whoosh which plays into the 'gig economy', further cheapening jobs and cutting costs.
![]() |
| We sacrificed a lot when we stopped using our high street shops |
BUT…that is purely an aside. Nobody is telling me Sainsbury's, Tesco, Asda and the rest of them aren't making enough proft to create more jobs than they are currently doing. I appreciate they are on razor-thin margins when it comes to food prices but how much is the self-scan tech costing to implement? It can't be cheap to first install and then maintain.
The future as it stands
While we are rightly worried about the impact of social media and AI on young people's ability to communicate as well as their mental health, it is worth questioning why supermarkets (and hey, fast food I see you too) are not part of this conversation too.
Young people say they are applying for jobs by the dozen to no success while employers will complain that they don't have the necessary experience. For me, it comes to the latter to solve the problem and have the means to deliver (at least part of) the solution.
--
*Of course older people are feeling the harms of social media but they have at least had the benefit of growing up in a smartphone-free world.
**I appreciate that the quieter aspect to the modern in-store experience will perhaps help neurodiverse people. It'd be great to have a balanced solution to continue supporting inclusion and accessibility.


Comments
Post a Comment